loading
36007 9th Ct SW, Federal Way, WA 98023
Monday - Friday 08:00 AM - 05:00 PM
36007 9th Ct SW, Federal Way, WA 98023
Monday - Friday 08:00 AM - 05:00 PM
Updates

Knob and Tube in Enatai and West Bellevue Cottages: Remodel Around It or Remove It First?

• 12 min read

By Alexandru Goncear, Owner and CEO, ElectON Enterprise. Washington electrical contractor license ELECTEL765MN.

If a remodel is going to open walls or ceilings with live knob and tube inside them, take the knob and tube out of those spaces first. Washington’s energy code expects the cavities you open to be filled with insulation, and the electrical code doesn’t allow insulation around knob and tube unless an electrician has surveyed the wiring and certified it in writing. Foam is never allowed.

Replacing the knob and tube in the rest of the house at the same time is a separate decision. It depends on the wiring’s condition, what your insurance carrier will accept, whether you plan to insulate other parts of the house, and how long you expect to keep the place. Some old cottages near the lake get torn down within a few years, and the answer is different for those.

Where knob and tube still turns up in Bellevue

Bellevue has much less prewar housing than Seattle or Tacoma. Most of the city went up after World War II, and Bellevue didn’t incorporate until 1953. The older houses that remain are mostly near Lake Washington: in Enatai next to Beaux Arts Village, around Meydenbauer Bay and Old Bellevue, and in pockets of West Bellevue.

William Meydenbauer filed his claim on the bay in 1869, and the bay became Bellevue’s first ferry landing. Until the first floating bridge opened in 1940, most trips from Seattle crossed the lake by boat, and what got built near the water in those decades was small: cabins, cottages and farmhouses. Knob and tube was the standard way to wire a house into the 1930s, before sheathed cable took over in the 1940s.

Many of those cottages have since been torn down or heavily remodeled. When we open the walls of one that survived, we still find cloth-covered wire and the occasional run of knob and tube, sometimes next to newer cable from an earlier partial rewire.

What knob and tube is, and why it’s a problem now

Knob and tube runs the hot and neutral as separate single wires. Porcelain knobs hold them off the framing, porcelain tubes carry them through joists and studs, and cloth sleeves called loom protect them where they enter a box. The wire is insulated with rubber wrapped in cloth, and there is no ground wire.

The system was designed to shed heat into open air, with the wires spaced apart inside empty walls and attics. A century later, several things work against it:

  • The rubber insulation gets brittle, especially near light fixtures and in hot attics, and it can crack when someone moves the wire.
  • With no ground, three-prong outlets on these circuits have nothing behind the third prong, and surge protectors can’t do their job.
  • Fuses get swapped for larger ones when they keep blowing, which lets the wire carry more current than it was meant to.
  • Later owners splice new cable onto the old wire, often outside a box and sometimes buried in a wall.
  • Insulation blown into the walls or attic traps the heat the wiring was designed to release.

None of that makes every run of knob and tube an emergency. Intact, untouched wiring on correctly sized fuses or breakers, in an open attic, can keep working. A remodel is usually what changes that, because the wire gets moved, the cavities get insulated, and circuits get extended.

How to tell whether yours is still live

Look in the attic and in the basement or crawlspace for porcelain knobs on the joists and pairs of single wires running a few inches apart. Two-prong outlets, a fuse box, and cloth-covered wire at the panel are other signs. Three-prong outlets don’t rule it out, because plenty of owners swapped outlets without adding a ground.

Finding knobs doesn’t mean the circuits are energized. In many partially rewired houses, the old wiring was disconnected and left where it was. Telling the difference means tracing circuits from the panel and testing at outlets and fixtures, and an electrician should do that before anyone plans a remodel around it.

Why opening the walls usually forces the decision

Once a wall or ceiling is open, two codes apply at the same time. Under Washington’s residential energy code, WAC 51-11R-50300, an alteration can skip the full new-construction requirements if the existing ceiling, wall or floor cavities exposed during the work are filled with insulation: at least R-15 in 2×4 walls and R-21 in 2×6 walls. Opening an exterior wall, in other words, means insulating it.

The National Electrical Code doesn’t allow concealed knob and tube in hollow spaces where insulation surrounds the conductors. Washington relaxes that with its own rule, WAC 296-46B-394, which allows loose or rolled insulation around existing knob and tube only when all of these are true:

  • A licensed electrical contractor surveys the wiring and certifies in writing that it is in good condition, with no improper overcurrent protection, no deteriorated insulation, and no improper connections or splices.
  • The insulation is Class I, with a flame spread rating of 25 or less.
  • Every knob and tube circuit is protected by a breaker or a Type S fuse sized to the wire’s 60 degree rating, which for typical 14 gauge knob and tube means 15 amps.

Foam insulation can’t be used with knob and tube under any circumstances. If your plans include spray foam in the walls or the roof, the knob and tube in those spaces has to go.

The same rule requires the electrical inspector to inspect any repairs, alterations or extensions to the wiring. Inside an opened wall, then, the choice is between removing the knob and tube there, or having it surveyed and certified and using only qualifying batts or loose fill. Once the plaster is off and the old wire is in plain view, removal is usually the easier call.

What the code asks of the remodeled rooms

The rooms you remodel get new wiring either way. A kitchen or bathroom remodel brings its own required circuits, GFCI protection and outlet spacing, and knob and tube can’t supply any of them. The electrical code also requires AFCI protection when branch circuit wiring in living areas is modified, replaced or extended, with a narrow exception for extensions of six feet or less that add no outlets.

The National Electrical Code does still technically permit extending an existing knob and tube installation. Doing so would leave you with an ungrounded circuit that needs AFCI protection anyway, spliced into wire that may be ninety years old, so a new circuit from the panel is the sensible approach. Our page on electrical work for remodels and renovations explains how we fit around a general contractor’s schedule.

Outside the remodel, Bellevue’s construction code lets existing equipment that was lawful when it went in stay in use, as long as it is maintained to its original design and isn’t creating a hazard. Nobody will make you rip out sound knob and tube in a bedroom you aren’t touching.

Three ways to handle it

Remove all of it before the remodel

This makes the most sense when the remodel opens a large share of the house, when your insurance carrier wants the knob and tube gone, or when you plan to stay for years. Rewiring while walls and ceilings are already open costs less than coming back later and fishing wire through finished plaster. Our knob and tube replacement work is done in zones so the house stays livable, and for a sense of scale, we published what full rewires have cost on recent jobs, itemized.

Remove it in the remodel area and plan the rest

If the remodel is one kitchen or one bathroom, rewire that area from the panel, take the knob and tube out of the opened walls, and schedule the rest of the house as a separate phase. The boundary between old and new needs care. Every splice belongs in an accessible box, no new cable gets spliced onto knob and tube inside a wall, and someone keeps a record of which circuits are still original. Skip that and you get the kind of partial rewires that splice into knob and tube in ways nobody can trace later.

Leave it for now

This is reasonable in a cottage that is likely to be torn down in a few years, or when the knob and tube sits outside the remodel, tests in good condition, and won’t be insulated over. At a minimum, have the fuse or breaker sizes checked against the wire and any amateur splices fixed, and don’t add insulation around it without the survey Washington requires. If a teardown is the plan, put the money toward new construction wiring for the rebuild instead.

Fuse boxes, panels and grounding

Houses with live knob and tube often still have a fuse box, or a small panel added decades ago with no free spaces. A remodel that adds kitchen and bathroom circuits usually needs more room than that, so replacing an old fuse box or an undersized panel often comes first. Any knob and tube circuits that stay in service get correctly sized breakers in the new panel, which also meets Washington’s overcurrent condition for insulation.

Circuits you keep stay ungrounded. Where outlets on them need replacing, the code allows GFCI protection with the outlets labeled “No equipment ground,” which protects people from shock but gives electronics no ground. We go through the options for grounding two-prong outlets on our outlet page.

Insurance and selling

Insurance carriers in Washington have gotten stricter about active knob and tube, and some won’t write or renew a policy until it is removed. If you have a letter from your carrier, bring it to the estimate so the scope of work matches what they ask for. When you sell, the buyer’s inspector will look in the attic, and a permitted, inspected rewire is the paperwork that answers their question.

Permits in Bellevue, and the towns next door

Inside city limits, the City of Bellevue issues electrical permits and inspects the work, with applications filed through MyBuildingPermit. A remodel or rewire gets a rough-in inspection with the walls open, before insulation and drywall, and a final inspection when the devices are in. Put the electrical rough-in early in the remodel schedule so it doesn’t hold up the insulation.

Not every house with a Bellevue address is in Bellevue. Beaux Arts Village sits right next to Enatai, and Medina and Clyde Hill border West Bellevue. Those towns don’t run their own electrical permits, so permits there come from the state Department of Labor and Industries. We check which office has jurisdiction at your address and file with that one.

What we look at before your remodel starts

We trace which circuits are knob and tube and which of those are live, check the fuse or breaker sizing, look at the condition of the wire in the attic and crawlspace, and look for old splices and buried junction boxes. We also go over the remodel plans to see which walls and ceilings will be opened and whether insulation or foam is planned.

You get a written, itemized estimate, free and with no trip charge. It lays out what we would remove now, what could reasonably wait, and what each phase costs, so you and your contractor can decide with the numbers in front of you.

Questions Bellevue homeowners ask about knob and tube

Is knob and tube illegal in Bellevue?

No. Existing knob and tube that was lawful when installed can stay in use if it is maintained to its original design and isn’t creating a hazard. The restrictions apply when you modify it, extend it, or insulate around it.

Can I add insulation to my attic if there’s knob and tube up there?

Only loose or rolled insulation rated Class I, and only after a licensed electrical contractor surveys the wiring and certifies in writing that it meets Washington’s conditions. Foam isn’t allowed with knob and tube. Many owners have the attic knob and tube removed first, since the attic is usually the easiest part of the house to rewire.

Can I extend a knob and tube circuit to add outlets in my remodel?

The code technically allows extensions of existing knob and tube, but the modified circuit needs AFCI protection and would still be ungrounded. Running a new circuit from the panel is the better choice.

Does dead knob and tube have to come out?

Wiring that is truly disconnected at the panel can usually stay in the walls, and Bellevue’s code doesn’t require a permit just to remove wiring. What matters is confirming it’s dead by tracing it at the panel and testing at the outlets.

Will my insurance cover a house with knob and tube?

It depends on the carrier. Some still will, some charge more, and some decline until it’s removed. Ask your carrier in writing what they need before you set the remodel scope.

How long does a knob and tube rewire take?

It depends on the size of the house and how much of it is open. Rewiring during a remodel, with the walls open, goes much faster than fishing wire through finished plaster. We put the schedule in writing with the estimate.

Before the demolition starts

If you own an older cottage in Enatai, around Meydenbauer Bay, or elsewhere in West Bellevue, find out what’s in the walls before the remodel plans are final. Our Kent office is about 20 miles down I-405, and the phone is answered around the clock. Schedule a knob and tube inspection or call (253) 508-7529. For the rest of what we do in the city, see our page for a licensed residential electrician in Bellevue.

Alexandru Goncear
Owner and CEO, ElectON Enterprise
Washington electrical contractor license ELECTEL765MN

Alex is a Washington-licensed electrician working on houses across King, Pierce and Snohomish County. He writes every estimate himself, after seeing the house, and stays the point of contact through the permit, the work and the final inspection.

ElectON Enterprise
Kent office, closest to Bellevue: 1609 Central Ave S Suite E, Kent, WA 98032
Headquarters: 36007 9th Ct SW, Federal Way, WA 98023
(253) 508-7529
Monday to Friday, 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM. Emergency line answered 24 hours.

Share this article